Not all toys are created equal. I tend to be somewhat obsessive when it comes to G's toys (for all things we purchase for her, for that matter). I research things to death, which is very easy to do with the internet. Things we stay away from, things that might have lead paint (yes, I've called several manufacturers about their products), plastics that might have PVC, BPA, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals, other things that may have harmful chemicals. Just because it's popular doesn't make it safe.
Recently, we bought a (used) Fisher-Price jumperoo. I didn't do as much research as I would have liked and on hindsight, may have preferred a different brand (I kind of liked the Baby Einstein jumperoo I saw at the store recently). When E brought it home and assembled it, he commented that it definitely doesn't "look" like G's other toys. I think it has something to do with the plasticy-ness of it, maybe the colors. I probably will not buy Fisher-Price again in the future, if I can help it.
So what toys do we like for her? We prefer to buy her toys that will help her developmentally, that are stimulating, and that can grow with her.
Lamaze: Great developmental
toys. We have the Octotunes (we've heard bad reviews that it's hard for little hands to get any sound out of, but it will be fun for us to play songs for her, and we just liked it anyways), and the other octopus activity toy (Octivity toy or something like that) where each leg has something unique, like crunchy sounds, different fabrics & ribbons, a mirror, rings, etc. She really likes the legs that crunch.
Manhattan Toy: G has the Skwish, which she loves, it's wooden, safe paint, and makes a soft tinkling sound. She can easily grab it and wave it around, and it's easy for her to keep holding on to it even if a few fingers open up. She also likes to suck on it and is really good at getting the balls on the end to her mouth. I also like several other of their toys that I haven't purchased yet, like some of their stuffed animals, which are just funky and cute. The Whoozit is very popular, and comes in many forms, but we don't have one for G yet, don't know if we will, I'm sort of on the fence about it, maybe just because it seems so trendy.
Kushies/Zolo: These are the BEST. We have their playmat, one of our first big purchases for G. It's reversible, one side just has lots of black/white patterns on it, the other side has funky colored patterns with different fabrics and toys that velcro on. There's also bars that arch across from the corners and you can hang stuff from them. In the beginning, we just used the black/white side for her tummy time. As she got better and started rolling, we used the colored side more. Then we discovered she likes to kick the arches in the corners in order to shake the stuff that's hanging. She's been using it since about week 3 or 4, and she definitely hasn't maxed out it's usage yet (just wait until she figures out the peek a boo toy). We just recently got her the stacking rings, Zolo Boa, (again, fun colors, lots of different fabrics and ribbons, and each ring makes a sound) and some stacking bean bags, Bean Stax, both of which are still advanced for G, but she can grow into them. Both have lots of parts to them, and for now, we have only given her one or two rings to play with, and a few of the beanbags (the one that crunches). Things I'm eyeing: the Hugbug, stuffed animal with funky fabrics/ribbons/colors, and the arms pull through, so that if you pull the left side, it makes the right side short, and then you can pull the right side to make the left side short.
Under the Nile: Good for clothes and toys. This is a locally based company that has all organic stuff. We have a few of the organic cotton fruits & vegetable teething toys for her. Some research suggests that babies/kids are more likely to eat stuff they are familiar with (have seen before) than those that are foreign. Granted, a toy tomato that has a head may not seem exactly the same as a real one, but it's closer than a ball or some other random toy. The fruits and veggies come in sets, but I've been cheap. A local store had some on sale that I've bought, so far, she only has the beans, banana, tomato, and mushroom. I'm eyeing the grapes, corn, asparagus, eggplant, broccoli, strawberry, and all the others for future purchases. BTW, the beans was the first one I bought, because it seemed like the skinniest for her to grab and get into her mouth. I somehow recall it being one of her first toys, but don't remember if I bought it before or after she was born.
There are lots of websites and blogs I read to get ideas and information about safe and educational/developmental toys.
If I feel up to it later, I'll put some links up so you can see exactly what toys I'm talking about. Amazon has a lot of them.